Race for next UN chief: Grynspan leads Security Council straw polls as Guterres's term nears its end
With António Guterres due to step down on 31 December, Costa Rica's Rebeca Grynspan has widened her lead in secret Security Council polls, but no candidate has yet cleared every hurdle, including a possible veto.
Key points
- António Guterres steps down as UN secretary-general on 31 December 2026, and the Security Council has held eight straw polls on his successor this year, Al Jazeera reported.
- In the latest poll, Costa Rica's Rebeca Grynspan received 12 encourage and 3 discourage votes, ahead of Argentina's Rafael Grossi and Guyana's Carolyn Rodrigues-Birkett, according to Al Jazeera.
- Grynspan has grown her support since late September, when The National reported she had 10 encourage votes in the fourth poll.
- A candidate needs nine council votes and no veto from the five permanent members before the General Assembly can appoint them, Al Jazeera explained.
- The UN has never been led by a woman in its 81-year history, The National noted.
With six weeks left before UN Secretary-General António Guterres leaves office on 31 December, Costa Rica's Rebeca Grynspan holds a clear lead in the Security Council's secret straw polls on his successor, Al Jazeera reported on Sunday, 15 November. In the most recent of eight polls held this year, Grynspan received 12 votes encouraging her candidacy and 3 discouraging it, the outlet said, but no candidate has yet gone through a round without a single discourage vote.
Where the candidates stand
According to Al Jazeera, Argentina's Rafael Grossi, who has headed the International Atomic Energy Agency since 2019, received 9 encourage votes, 4 discourage votes and 2 no-opinion votes in the latest round. Guyana's UN ambassador, Carolyn Rodrigues-Birkett, received 8 encourage, 5 discourage and 2 no-opinion votes.
That marks progress for Grynspan since late September. The National reported that in the fourth straw poll, held on 29 September, she drew 10 encourage votes, 3 discourage votes and 2 with no opinion, while Rodrigues-Birkett and Grossi each had 8 encourage votes. Grynspan, a former vice president of Costa Rica, has led the UN Conference on Trade and Development, known as UNCTAD, since 2021, according to The National.
Eight candidates are in the race, Al Jazeera said. Besides the three front-runners, they include Ecuador's María Fernanda Espinosa and Ivonne A-Baki, the United Arab Emirates' Lana Nusseibeh, Türkiye's Feridun Sinirlioğlu and Uganda's Olara Otunnu.
How the choice is made
The 15-member Security Council effectively picks the secretary-general, Al Jazeera explained. Under Article 97 of the UN Charter, the council recommends a candidate who wins at least nine votes with no veto from any of the five permanent members, China, France, Russia, the United Kingdom and the United States. The General Assembly then appoints that person, and it has never rejected a council recommendation.
In straw polls, members mark each candidate as encourage, discourage or no opinion. The results are meant to stay secret but often leak, and later rounds use coloured ballots so that votes from permanent members can be told apart, according to Al Jazeera. Because the permanent members' individual votes are not known, it is unclear whether any of Grynspan's discourage votes came from a country that could block her, a point an International Peace Institute adviser also raised to The National in September.
Calls for a more open process
Jane Kinninmont, chief executive of the United Nations Association UK, told Al Jazeera that the selection has traditionally been closed and secretive but has opened up because of campaigning by civil society and member states. She said there is growing resentment over the veto and suggested the council could put two or three names to the General Assembly. Al Jazeera's UN correspondent Gabriel Elizondo said the permanent five are unlikely to give up their power to shape the outcome.
A first woman at the top?
The UN has never been led by a woman in its 81-year history, The National noted. Al Jazeera said Grynspan would be the first woman to hold the post if she is chosen.
What happens next
The UN Charter does not say what happens if no successor is chosen by 31 December, Al Jazeera reported. Options include appointing someone for a shorter term, a compromise like the one that produced Kofi Annan in 1996, or asking a senior UN official to oversee operations for a period. Guterres has said he hopes and expects to be back in Portugal from 1 January, according to Al Jazeera.