Skip to content
PJM

Zelensky says US floated NATO membership for Ukraine in exchange for leaving Donbas

Ukraine's president said it was the first time NATO membership had been tied to territorial concessions, and that any deal would need strong security guarantees and approval by Ukrainians in a referendum.

Key points

  • Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky said US negotiators raised the idea of NATO membership for Ukraine if it withdrew from the parts of Donbas it still controls, according to the Kyiv Independent and Al Jazeera.
  • Zelensky said it was the first time NATO membership had been linked to territorial concessions, both outlets reported.
  • He said Ukrainians would have the final say in a referendum, but only with a full package of security guarantees, military and financial support and a recovery plan, the outlets reported.
  • The cited reports carried no on-the-record response from US officials or the Kremlin to Zelensky's account.

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky has said that US negotiators raised the possibility of Ukraine joining NATO if it pulled out of the parts of the eastern Donbas region that it still holds, according to the Kyiv Independent and Al Jazeera, which drew on Reuters and AP. Zelensky made the remarks to reporters, and his office released them on Saturday, 14 November. He said it was the first time the question of NATO membership had been linked to giving up territory, both outlets reported.

What Zelensky says was proposed

According to the Kyiv Independent, Zelensky described the US side as asking whether Ukraine would withdraw from Donbas if it were able to join the alliance. Al Jazeera reported that the areas in question are ones Russia does not currently control, and that Zelensky said he had refused to give up territory.

Russian President Vladimir Putin has long described Ukrainian membership of NATO as a red line and cited it as one reason for the 2022 invasion, Al Jazeera noted. Zelensky called Putin's push to redraw borders in Europe dangerous, the outlet said.

His conditions for any deal

Zelensky said Ukrainians would have the final word on any territorial question through a national referendum, both outlets reported. But he said that would only happen if the United States and other partners offered a complete package. According to the Kyiv Independent, that package would include guarantees backed by NATO and the European Union, a strong Ukrainian army, time-limited financial support and a recovery plan. Al Jazeera described it as security guarantees, military and reconstruction funding and a recovery plan.

He said any agreement would come "without any recognition of the occupied territories as Russian," the Kyiv Independent reported. Al Jazeera said he also ruled out neutrality for Ukraine, noting that it would require a change to the constitution.

Security guarantees still unclear

The Kyiv Independent reported that Zelensky wants protections modelled on NATO's Article 5 mutual defence clause as a minimum, and that Washington had suggested something resembling Articles 4 and 5. He said that when he asked whether US troops would be stationed in Ukraine, the answer from the US side was no, and that US officials described the guarantees as bilateral, similar to those Israel has. Zelensky added: "we need specifics, and we don't have them yet," according to the outlet.

Talks and fighting continue

The comments followed US-mediated talks between Ukraine and Russia in Abu Dhabi on 10 and 11 November, the Kyiv Independent reported. Al Jazeera said EU leaders meeting in Ireland agreed that Europe's negotiating team would be made up of the United Kingdom, France, Germany, Italy and Poland together with EU officials, and would talk to US and Ukrainian officials but not to Russia.

The fighting has not stopped. According to Al Jazeera, Russian officials said about 1,200 Ukrainian drones were launched at Russia on Friday, while Ukraine reported attacks on a hospital and the port of Odesa.

What to watch

The cited reports did not include an on-the-record response from US officials or from the Kremlin to Zelensky's account, so the details of the US idea rest on his description. The next steps to watch are whether Washington confirms the proposal and how the new European negotiating team takes part in the next round of talks, according to the reports.